Marty Lurie Talks San Francisco Giants Baseball
//

Category — Inside the Press Box

Why McGwire Should Not be in the Hall of Fame

This reporter followed Mark McGwire’s career from 1986 until 1997 with the Oakland Athletics. As a matter of fact I covered the Pre Olympic game at Candlestick Park years before he became a professional and was playing third base for the USA Olympic team when they played the Japanese Olympic squad.

Mark McGwire set a rookie record with 49 home runs in 1987, that year he also drove 118 runs and was part of the best "one two" punch in baseball with fellow bashers José Canseco. McGwire was second Rookie of The Year for A’S 1987 following José who won it in 1986. Then came shortstop Walt Weiss who won it in 1988. The last time A’S had 3 Rookies of The Year in a row. Those where the days. Three consecutive trips to the World Series(88-89-90) the A’S were the envy of the baseball world. A team loaded with talent and impact players like Canseco and McGwire, people came in early to the Oakland Coliseum just to watch them in batting practice. There is something about sluggers that people are drawn to.

Big Mac was greatly responsible together with Sammy Sosa in 1998 for reviving baseball and he and Sosa are crediting by many for "saving" the game after the nasty work stoppage in 1994-95. McGwire retired before baseball began testing for illegal performance enhancing drugs, better know as steroids. There is no doubt McGwire deserves to be in this most recent Hall of Fame ballot together with Tony Gwynn and Cal Ripken Jr. However the contrast here is immense. Gwynn and Ripken will be elected without any controversy, Gwynn was a pure hitter who won eight batting titles and Ripken broke Lou Gehrig’s consecutive games streak and was one of the most popular players ever. Big Mac is number seven in the all-time home run list with 583, his 70 home runs in 1998 was an incredible feat until Barry Bonds hit 73 in 2001. A lot has happened since 1998 and today almost nine years later the names of Canseco, Sosa, Bonds, Palmeiro and yes, McGwire all have a huge dark cloud over them.

McGwire testified in March 2005 in front of Congress during the hearings on steroids. He was there with his "buddy" José Canseco Sammy Sosa and Rafael Palmeiro. McGwire’s showing at those hearings was ‘to say the least’ disappointing. Canseco accused everybody, Palmeiro pulled a Clinton with his finger, Sosa had more interpreters that he really needed and McGwire in my opinion was the worse, he didn’t say much. He sat there like an idiot, half pregnant, neither confirming or denying the accusations. I covered all these guys during their playing days, talked with them, interviewed them on may occasions and of all those players I mentioned that have retired since, McGwire was always the most difficult.

[Read more →]

December 6, 2006   No Comments

Was McGwire GOOD Enough?

Rick Kaplan
Staff Writer
OAKLAND (November 30) – Forget about holding steroid or supplement use against him.
You say performance enhancers are an unfair advantage, that that they un-level the playing field?
There has never been a "level playing field." Sandy Koufax, Whitey Ford, and Gaylord Perry made sure of that. Koufax use illegal pain-killers, Ford and Perry brazenly doctored the ball. Aaron and Schmidt needed a boost to get through doubleheaders, and Mantle got help from his friends, like racketeer Denny McClain.
Ty Cobb and Tris Speaker bet on games. Do you think they were the only ones?
Tommy John, on the current list of nominees, got a new arm, and a new career, as have hundreds of surgery-enhanced pitchers since baseball’s first bionic experiment. And today’s stars, Bonds, Clemens, Giambi, Sheffield, and on and on, haven’t they have been just following in the tradition of those illustrious enhancers before them?

[Read more →]

November 30, 2006   No Comments

should he or shouldn't he?

There has been much speculation about Mark McGwire’s possible entry into Baseball’s Hall of Fame.
McGwire was Rookie of the Year in 1987 and set a rookie record for most home runs in a season by
a rookie. He played with the A’s until mid 1997 when he was traded to the St. louis Cardinals.
When he left in 1997, McGwire had hit over 300 homers and had been sidelined by a foot injury
that cost him parts of 2 seasons. In addition,the strike in 1994 cost all the players the last 2 months of that season.

McGwire went to St.Louis and went on a tear. He hit over 50 homers in 1997 and then shattered
Roger Maris’ record by hitting 70 homers in 1998. Who could forget the remarkable race for the home run crown by Sammy Sosa and Mark Mcgwire. Those 2 men brought the fans back into the game. After the strike in 1994,many fans swore off baseball completely.McGwire retired 5 years ago
when a cranky knee would no longer allow him to play the game and he ended his career with 583
home runs. Normally, a player with those numbers would be a lock for Cooperstown. However, McGwire may not make it to the hall on the 1st ballott and may not make it all. Why?
His former teammate,Jose Canseco, has made allegations that McGwire used steroids to bulk up.
Steroids were not illegal substances at the time. Rather than put these allegations to rest before a congressional committee, Mcgwire refused to testify and looked like a guilty man doing so.
What was illegal was obtaining prescription drugs without a proper prescription. No team doctor would ever order such substances. Also the trainers would not be silent. They could tell if a player
was getting injections.

No one will ever know the truth. All I can say is that the stalls in the bathroom are too small to
hold two huge men giving each other shots. McGwire has put his baseball life behind him and has
moved on. There is no proof that he ever used steroids other than Canseco’s word. I have not
heard any other teammate come forward and say that they saw such behavior.

It is clear that McGwire used nutritional substances that may have cointained a precursor of an anabolic steroid. However,it was not illegal. McGwire als o worked out in the weight room and
had biceps like Popeye. McGwire is 6’5" tall and relatively thin for a man that size. He had
back problems over the years due to the tremeendous torque placed on his back when he would swing at a pitch.

I do not have a vote for the Hall of Fame,but if I did I would vote for his entry into that august body. I believe that a person is innocent till proven guilty and that the individual has a right
not to testify. Using the 5th ammendment,which he didn’t do, does not presume guilt. The only finger pointing at him is the one belonging to Jose Canseco. I do not believe that there is there
there and that the sportswriters should elect him to the hall.

Jerry Feitelberg
[Read more →]

November 29, 2006   No Comments

SHORT STORY When We Almost Lost the A's

A Short Story . . .
WHEN WE ALMOST LOST THE A’s
Rick Kaplan, Jr.
Staff Writer
OAKLAND (November 26, 2043)
Driving by the huge excavation on I-880 in Fremont, my grandfather would always smile while my brothers and I would make up stories about what had happened to cause that big hole in the ground. We thought it had the look of a giant meteor having impacted the earth many millennia ago.
Grandpa told us that for Oakland what happened there had a bigger impact than any meteor could make.
Today, when I pass by that same hole, near the old GM factory, where they hold swap meets and the occasional soccer or cricket match, rodeos, demolition derbies, or for whatever else they can rent out an unfinished high-tech graveyard, I still wonder what it was all about in the first place.

Click below for more of Rick’s story.

[Read more →]

November 27, 2006   No Comments

Crisco Field

Rick Kaplan
Staff Writer

OAKLAND (November 19) – Green grass and freshly raked clay. A sunny day. The crack of the bat. The rise of the crowd.

That’s Baseball. Oakland Athletics fans don’t need anything else.
No three story Coke bottles. No faux brick breweries in the outfield, or imitation Wrigleyville roof seats. No swimming pools or splash hits. And, definitely, no interactive monitors and stock quotes at every seat.
It’s about that ritual march, across the bridge, to and from the BART station. Shoulder-to-shoulder with friendly fans of every description, win or lose. Even the incessant "need two?" of the scalpers, and the guys hawking their baseball chotchkey. It’s a melody you won’t hear in Fremont.

[Read more →]

November 19, 2006   No Comments

Go ahead laugh at Fremont

A deal that involved the Oakland Athletics
moving to Fremont was made in
San José, by the Commissioner of
baseball, Cisco representatives and
the owners of the Oakland A’s.

By Amaury Pi-González [Read more →]

November 14, 2006   No Comments

The South Bay is Sports Central

If you live in San Francisco or even Oakland
you might want to consider moving to the
South Bay. The San Jose Sharks play in the
beautiful HP Arena in downtown San Jose and now the Oakland Athletics and San Francisco 49ers are
planning a move south. All-of-a-sudden Silicon Valley is rapidly becoming Sports Central.

By Amaury Pi-Gonzalez [Read more →]

November 10, 2006   No Comments

Oakland Turned Us Down, Cries Wolff

Rick Kaplan
Staff Writer

OAKLAND (November 7) – "We have spent more than two years scouring the city for a suitable location for a new ballpark. The latest NSA and NASA spy satellite imagery–not even Google’s maps–failed to turn up a single new site within Oakland on which we could plan our new park."

When asked why the potentially picturesqe Oak-to-Ninth site along the Estuary, or the empty, enormous former Oakland Army Base, did not receive consideration, Wolff replied that "We never saw them on the satellite pictures."

Click below for more! [Read more →]

November 7, 2006   No Comments

The San Jose Athletics of Fremont

Commissioner Bud Selig will come to the
Bay Area to make the official announcement.
The Oakland Athletics are moving to the
City of Fremont. Selig will be here November 14.

By Amaury Pi-Gonzalez [Read more →]

November 6, 2006   No Comments

My Scariest Halloween Nightmare by Rick Kaplan

Rick Kaplan
Staff Writer

OAKLAND (October 31) – I am in a really spooky Busch Stadium, surrounded by thousands and thousands of giddy, red-clad Pat Robertson clones, who have just marched over from the world’s largest Pancake House.

In my clammy vision, I am begging not to be sent to Winter Sports Purgatory two days early. I am reaching for one last grasp of the horsehide, but face-offs, three point lines, and first downs are now everywhere.

An enormous scoreboard clock ticks down to two minutes. Everything stops, except David Eckstein. He shoulders a bat that is a foot taller than he is, and strides to the plate as the earth shudders.

C’mon, Tigers, do something! But that can’t be! All their fielders are pitchers?

Click below for more! [Read more →]

October 31, 2006   No Comments